18 oct 2022|18:45FinalGateshead2 - 1AltrinchamFA CupGateshead International StadiumNeilson RoadGatesheadGlobal18 oct 2022|18:45FA CupGateshead International StadiumNeilson RoadGatesheadGlobalFinal
14 oct 2023|14:00FinalAltrincham0 - 1Oldham AthleticFA CupThe J. Davidson StadiumMoss LaneAltrinchamGlobal14 oct 2023|14:00FA CupThe J. Davidson StadiumMoss LaneAltrinchamGlobalFinal
12 oct 2024|14:00FinalAltrincham1 - 1Solihull MoorsFA CupThe J. Davidson StadiumMoss LaneAltrinchamGlobal12 oct 2024|14:00FA CupThe J. Davidson StadiumMoss LaneAltrinchamGlobalFinal
15 oct 2024|18:45Final (Pen.)Solihull Moors2 - 2AltrinchamFA CupThe ARMCO ArenaDamson ParkwaySolihullGlobal15 oct 2024|18:45FA CupThe ARMCO ArenaDamson ParkwaySolihullGlobalFinal (Pen.)
11 oct 2025|14:00FinalAltrincham2 - 2Harborough TownFA CupThe J. Davidson StadiumMoss LaneAltrinchamGlobal11 oct 2025|14:00FA CupThe J. Davidson StadiumMoss LaneAltrinchamGlobalFinal
14 oct 2025|18:45Final (Pró.)Harborough Town0 - 3AltrinchamFA CupBowden ParkBowden ParkMarket HarboroughGlobal14 oct 2025|18:45FA CupBowden ParkBowden ParkMarket HarboroughGlobalFinal (Pró.)
1 nov 2025|15:00FinalSlough Town2 - 1AltrinchamFA CupArbour ParkStoke RoadSloughGlobal1 nov 2025|15:00FA CupArbour ParkStoke RoadSloughGlobalFinal
17 oct 2026|14:00FinalAltrincham0 - 0United of ManchesterFA CupThe J. Davidson StadiumMoss LaneAltrinchamGlobal17 oct 2026|14:00FA CupThe J. Davidson StadiumMoss LaneAltrinchamGlobalFinal
20 oct 2026|18:45FinalUnited of Manchester2 - 6AltrinchamFA CupBroadhurst Park310 Lightbowne Road. MostonManchesterGlobal20 oct 2026|18:45FA CupBroadhurst Park310 Lightbowne Road. MostonManchesterGlobalFinal
7 nov 2026|17:30Final (Pen.)Altrincham2 - 2Notts CountyFA CupThe J. Davidson StadiumMoss LaneAltrinchamGlobal7 nov 2026|17:30FA CupThe J. Davidson StadiumMoss LaneAltrinchamGlobalFinal (Pen.)