5 nov 2022|15:00FinalGateshead2 - 3StevenageFA CupGateshead International StadiumNeilson RoadGatesheadGlobal5 nov 2022|15:00FA CupGateshead International StadiumNeilson RoadGatesheadGlobalFinal
14 oct 2023|14:00FinalStourbridge0 - 3GatesheadFA CupWar Memorial Athletic GroundWar Memorial Athletic GroundStourbridge, West MidlandsGlobal14 oct 2023|14:00FA CupWar Memorial Athletic GroundWar Memorial Athletic GroundStourbridge, West MidlandsGlobalFinal
4 nov 2023|15:00FinalYeovil Town3 - 2GatesheadFA CupHuish Park StadiumLufton Way, LuftonYeovilGlobal4 nov 2023|15:00FA CupHuish Park StadiumLufton Way, LuftonYeovilGlobalFinal
12 oct 2024|14:30FinalHednesford Town1 - 1GatesheadFA CupKeys ParkKeys Park RoadHednesfordGlobal12 oct 2024|14:30FA CupKeys ParkKeys Park RoadHednesfordGlobalFinal
15 oct 2024|18:45FinalGateshead1 - 3Hednesford TownFA CupGateshead International StadiumNeilson RoadGatesheadGlobal15 oct 2024|18:45FA CupGateshead International StadiumNeilson RoadGatesheadGlobalFinal
11 oct 2025|14:00FinalAveley0 - 3GatesheadFA CupParkside StadiumParkside StadiumAveleyGlobal11 oct 2025|14:00FA CupParkside StadiumParkside StadiumAveleyGlobalFinal
1 nov 2025|15:00FinalAFC Wimbledon0 - 2GatesheadFA CupCherry Red Records StadiumPlough Lane, WimbledonTBDGlobal1 nov 2025|15:00FA CupCherry Red Records StadiumPlough Lane, WimbledonTBDGlobalFinal
7 dic 2025|15:30FinalGateshead0 - 2WalsallFA CupGateshead International StadiumNeilson RoadGatesheadGlobal7 dic 2025|15:30FA CupGateshead International StadiumNeilson RoadGatesheadGlobalFinal
17 oct 2026|14:00FinalGateshead1 - 1Stafford RangersFA CupGateshead International StadiumNeilson RoadGatesheadGlobal17 oct 2026|14:00FA CupGateshead International StadiumNeilson RoadGatesheadGlobalFinal
20 oct 2026|18:45FinalStafford Rangers5 - 0GatesheadFA CupMarston RoadMarston RoadStaffordGlobal20 oct 2026|18:45FA CupMarston RoadMarston RoadStaffordGlobalFinal