5 ago. 2023|14:00FimAtherstone Town3 - 0Stone Old AlleyniansFA CupSheepy RoadSheepy RoadSheepy RoadGlobal5 ago. 2023|14:00FA CupSheepy RoadSheepy RoadSheepy RoadGlobalFim
19 ago. 2023|14:00FimAtherstone Town2 - 0GresleyFA CupSheepy RoadSheepy RoadSheepy RoadGlobal19 ago. 2023|14:00FA CupSheepy RoadSheepy RoadSheepy RoadGlobalFim
2 set. 2023|14:00FimStafford Rangers2 - 0Atherstone TownFA CupMarston RoadMarston RoadStaffordGlobal2 set. 2023|14:00FA CupMarston RoadMarston RoadStaffordGlobalFim
3 ago. 2024|14:00DesconhecidoAFC WulfruniansVSAtherstone TownFA Cup3 ago. 2024|14:00FA CupDesconhecido
17 ago. 2024|14:00DesconhecidoAtherstone TownVSKidsgrove AthleticFA CupGimhae Civil StadiumGimhae Civil StadiumGimhaeGlobal17 ago. 2024|14:00FA CupGimhae Civil StadiumGimhae Civil StadiumGimhaeGlobalDesconhecido
16 ago. 2025|14:00FimBedworth United0 - 2Atherstone TownFA CupThe OvalCoventry RoadBedworthGlobal16 ago. 2025|14:00FA CupThe OvalCoventry RoadBedworthGlobalFim
30 ago. 2025|14:00FimRushall Olympic5 - 1Atherstone TownFA CupDales LaneDaw End, Bosty Lane, RushallWalsallGlobal30 ago. 2025|14:00FA CupDales LaneDaw End, Bosty Lane, RushallWalsallGlobalFim
8 ago. 2026|14:00FimNewcastle Town2 - 1Atherstone TownFA CupLyme Valley StadiumBuckmaster Avenue, ClaytonNewcastle-under-LymeGlobal8 ago. 2026|14:00FA CupLyme Valley StadiumBuckmaster Avenue, ClaytonNewcastle-under-LymeGlobalFim