8 ago 2023|18:45FinalLoughborough Dynamo0 - 2Cleethorpes TownFA CupNanpantan Sports GroundNanpantan RoadLoughboroughGlobal8 ago 2023|18:45FA CupNanpantan Sports GroundNanpantan RoadLoughboroughGlobalFinal
19 ago 2023|14:00FinalStocksbridge Park Steels0 - 1Cleethorpes TownFA CupBracken MoorBracken MoorStocksbridge, South YorkshireGlobal19 ago 2023|14:00FA CupBracken MoorBracken MoorStocksbridge, South YorkshireGlobalFinal
2 sept 2023|14:00FinalCleethorpes Town2 - 1Leicester RoadFA CupSanta Elena Sporting ComplexSanta Elena Sporting ComplexSanta ElenaGlobal2 sept 2023|14:00FA CupSanta Elena Sporting ComplexSanta Elena Sporting ComplexSanta ElenaGlobalFinal
16 sept 2023|14:00FinalCleethorpes Town2 - 4Alfreton TownFA CupSanta Elena Sporting ComplexSanta Elena Sporting ComplexSanta ElenaGlobal16 sept 2023|14:00FA CupSanta Elena Sporting ComplexSanta Elena Sporting ComplexSanta ElenaGlobalFinal
3 ago 2024|14:00DesconocidoKimberley Miners WelfareVSCleethorpes TownFA CupThe Stag GroundThe Stag GroundNottinghamGlobal3 ago 2024|14:00FA CupThe Stag GroundThe Stag GroundNottinghamGlobalDesconocido
17 ago 2024|14:00DesconocidoCleethorpes TownVSQuornFA CupSanta Elena Sporting ComplexSanta Elena Sporting ComplexSanta ElenaGlobal17 ago 2024|14:00FA CupSanta Elena Sporting ComplexSanta Elena Sporting ComplexSanta ElenaGlobalDesconocido
31 ago 2024|14:00FinalMalvern Town0 - 1Cleethorpes TownFA CupHD Anywhere StadiumHD Anywhere StadiumMalvernGlobal31 ago 2024|14:00FA CupHD Anywhere StadiumHD Anywhere StadiumMalvernGlobalFinal
14 sept 2024|14:00FinalKettering Town1 - 0Cleethorpes TownFA CupLatimer ParkPolwell Lane, Burton LatimerKetteringGlobal14 sept 2024|14:00FA CupLatimer ParkPolwell Lane, Burton LatimerKetteringGlobalFinal
30 ago 2025|14:00FinalCarlton Town3 - 0Cleethorpes TownFA CupBill Stokeld StadiumStoke Lane, GedlingCarltonGlobal30 ago 2025|14:00FA CupBill Stokeld StadiumStoke Lane, GedlingCarltonGlobalFinal
5 sept 2026|14:00FinalCleethorpes Town1 - 2Newcastle TownFA CupBradley Football Development CentreBradley RoadGrimsbyGlobal5 sept 2026|14:00FA CupBradley Football Development CentreBradley RoadGrimsbyGlobalFinal