2 dic 2023|15:00FinalSutton United3 - 0HorshamFA CupVBS Community StadiumGander Green LaneSuttonGlobal2 dic 2023|15:00FA CupVBS Community StadiumGander Green LaneSuttonGlobalFinal
6 ene 2024|15:00FinalPlymouth Argyle3 - 1Sutton UnitedFA CupHome ParkGilbert LanePlymouthGlobal6 ene 2024|15:00FA CupHome ParkGilbert LanePlymouthGlobalFinal
12 oct 2024|14:00FinalChertsey Town1 - 3Sutton UnitedFA CupAlwyns Lane Football GroundAlwyns LaneChertseyGlobal12 oct 2024|14:00FA CupAlwyns Lane Football GroundAlwyns LaneChertseyGlobalFinal
3 nov 2024|12:30FinalSutton United0 - 1Birmingham CityFA CupVBS Community StadiumGander Green LaneSuttonGlobal3 nov 2024|12:30FA CupVBS Community StadiumGander Green LaneSuttonGlobalFinal
11 oct 2025|11:30FinalFarnham Town3 - 3Sutton UnitedFA CupThe Memorial Ground FarnhamThe Memorial Ground FarnhamFarnhamGlobal11 oct 2025|11:30FA CupThe Memorial Ground FarnhamThe Memorial Ground FarnhamFarnhamGlobalFinal
14 oct 2025|18:45Final (Pró.)Sutton United3 - 2Farnham TownFA CupVBS Community StadiumGander Green LaneSuttonGlobal14 oct 2025|18:45FA CupVBS Community StadiumGander Green LaneSuttonGlobalFinal (Pró.)
1 nov 2025|15:00FinalSutton United2 - 1AFC Telford UnitedFA CupVBS Community StadiumGander Green LaneSuttonGlobal1 nov 2025|15:00FA CupVBS Community StadiumGander Green LaneSuttonGlobalFinal
6 dic 2025|17:15Final (Pró.)Sutton United1 - 2Shrewsbury TownFA CupVBS Community StadiumGander Green LaneSuttonGlobal6 dic 2025|17:15FA CupVBS Community StadiumGander Green LaneSuttonGlobalFinal (Pró.)
17 oct 2026|14:00FinalSutton United1 - 0Truro CityFA CupVBS Community StadiumGander Green LaneSuttonGlobal17 oct 2026|14:00FA CupVBS Community StadiumGander Green LaneSuttonGlobalFinal
7 nov 2026|15:00FinalGuiseley1 - 0Sutton UnitedFA CupNethermoor ParkOtley RoadGuiseleyGlobal7 nov 2026|15:00FA CupNethermoor ParkOtley RoadGuiseleyGlobalFinal