2 sept 2023|14:00FinalMarlow2 - 0AFC Croydon AthleticFA CupAlfred Davis Memorial GroundOak Tree RoadMarlowGlobal2 sept 2023|14:00FA CupAlfred Davis Memorial GroundOak Tree RoadMarlowGlobalFinal
3 ago 2024|14:00DesconocidoAFC Croydon AthleticVSGuildford CityFA CupThe Keith Tuckey StadiumThe Keith Tuckey StadiumThe Keith Tuckey StadiumGlobal3 ago 2024|14:00FA CupThe Keith Tuckey StadiumThe Keith Tuckey StadiumThe Keith Tuckey StadiumGlobalDesconocido
17 ago 2024|14:00DesconocidoAFC Croydon AthleticVSVCD AthleticFA CupThe Keith Tuckey StadiumThe Keith Tuckey StadiumThe Keith Tuckey StadiumGlobal17 ago 2024|14:00FA CupThe Keith Tuckey StadiumThe Keith Tuckey StadiumThe Keith Tuckey StadiumGlobalDesconocido
31 ago 2024|14:00FinalBurgess Hill Town2 - 1AFC Croydon AthleticFA CupLeylands ParkMaple DriveBurgess HillGlobal31 ago 2024|14:00FA CupLeylands ParkMaple DriveBurgess HillGlobalFinal
2 ago 2025|14:00FinalAFC Croydon Athletic3 - 0RoffeyFA CupThe Keith Tuckey StadiumThe Keith Tuckey StadiumThe Keith Tuckey StadiumGlobal2 ago 2025|14:00FA CupThe Keith Tuckey StadiumThe Keith Tuckey StadiumThe Keith Tuckey StadiumGlobalFinal
16 ago 2025|14:00FinalTooting & Mitcham United0 - 1AFC Croydon AthleticFA CupImperial FieldsBishopsford RoadMordenGlobal16 ago 2025|14:00FA CupImperial FieldsBishopsford RoadMordenGlobalFinal
30 ago 2025|14:00FinalSittingbourne1 - 2AFC Croydon AthleticFA CupThe WE Mannin StadiumBroadoak RoadSittingbourneGlobal30 ago 2025|14:00FA CupThe WE Mannin StadiumBroadoak RoadSittingbourneGlobalFinal
13 sept 2025|14:00FinalHampton & Richmond4 - 2AFC Croydon AthleticFA CupBeveree StadiumBeaver CloseHamptonGlobal13 sept 2025|14:00FA CupBeveree StadiumBeaver CloseHamptonGlobalFinal
23 ago 2026|14:00FinalMidhurst & Easebourne1 - 3AFC Croydon AthleticFA Cup23 ago 2026|14:00FA CupFinal
5 sept 2026|14:00FinalLeatherhead3 - 0AFC Croydon AthleticFA CupFetcham GroveGuildford RoadLeatherheadGlobal5 sept 2026|14:00FA CupFetcham GroveGuildford RoadLeatherheadGlobalFinal