30 Sep 2023|14:00FTCarshalton Athletic3 - 3Cray Valley (PM)FA CupWar Memorial Sports GroundColston AvenueCarshaltonGlobal30 Sep 2023|14:00FA CupWar Memorial Sports GroundColston AvenueCarshaltonGlobalFT
31 Aug 2024|14:00FTCarshalton Athletic3 - 1Haywards Heath TownFA CupWar Memorial Sports GroundColston AvenueCarshaltonGlobal31 Aug 2024|14:00FA CupWar Memorial Sports GroundColston AvenueCarshaltonGlobalFT
14 Sep 2024|14:00FTCarshalton Athletic1 - 0South ParkFA CupWar Memorial Sports GroundColston AvenueCarshaltonGlobal14 Sep 2024|14:00FA CupWar Memorial Sports GroundColston AvenueCarshaltonGlobalFT
28 Sep 2024|14:00FTCarshalton Athletic3 - 2Melksham TownFA CupWar Memorial Sports GroundColston AvenueCarshaltonGlobal28 Sep 2024|14:00FA CupWar Memorial Sports GroundColston AvenueCarshaltonGlobalFT
12 Oct 2024|14:00FTBoreham Wood4 - 0Carshalton AthleticFA CupMeadow ParkBroughinge RoadBorehamwoodGlobal12 Oct 2024|14:00FA CupMeadow ParkBroughinge RoadBorehamwoodGlobalFT
30 Aug 2025|14:00FTCarshalton Athletic0 - 0Wingate & FinchleyFA CupWar Memorial Sports GroundColston AvenueCarshaltonGlobal30 Aug 2025|14:00FA CupWar Memorial Sports GroundColston AvenueCarshaltonGlobalFT
2 Sep 2025|18:45FTWingate & Finchley3 - 2Carshalton AthleticFA CupThe Maurice Rebak Stadium (London)The Maurice Rebak Stadium (London)LondonGlobal2 Sep 2025|18:45FA CupThe Maurice Rebak Stadium (London)The Maurice Rebak Stadium (London)LondonGlobalFT
5 Sep 2026|14:00FTChertsey Town1 - 1Carshalton AthleticFA CupAlwyns Lane Football GroundAlwyns LaneChertseyGlobal5 Sep 2026|14:00FA CupAlwyns Lane Football GroundAlwyns LaneChertseyGlobalFT
7 Sep 2026|18:45FTCarshalton Athletic1 - 2Chertsey TownFA CupWar Memorial Sports GroundColston AvenueCarshaltonGlobal7 Sep 2026|18:45FA CupWar Memorial Sports GroundColston AvenueCarshaltonGlobalFT
EnglandWar Memorial Sports GroundCarshalton
EnglandWar Memorial Sports GroundCarshaltonEnglandWar Memorial Sports GroundCarshalton