24 Aug 2019|14:00FTFrickley Athletic0 - 1Tadcaster AlbionFA CupWestfield Lane StadiumWestfield LaneSouth ElmsallGlobal24 Aug 2019|14:00FA CupWestfield Lane StadiumWestfield LaneSouth ElmsallGlobalFT
12 Sep 2020|14:00FTFrickley Athletic3 - 1Newcastle Benfield FCFA CupWestfield Lane StadiumWestfield LaneSouth ElmsallGlobal12 Sep 2020|14:00FA CupWestfield Lane StadiumWestfield LaneSouth ElmsallGlobalFT
22 Sep 2020|18:45FTFrickley Athletic0 - 1MarineFA CupWestfield Lane StadiumWestfield LaneSouth ElmsallGlobal22 Sep 2020|18:45FA CupWestfield Lane StadiumWestfield LaneSouth ElmsallGlobalFT
21 Aug 2021|14:00FTFrickley Athletic0 - 3Sunderland RCAFA CupWestfield Lane StadiumWestfield LaneSouth ElmsallGlobal21 Aug 2021|14:00FA CupWestfield Lane StadiumWestfield LaneSouth ElmsallGlobalFT
7 Aug 2022|12:00FTWhickham2 - 1Frickley AthleticFA CupThe Glebe GroundThe Glebe GroundWhickhamGlobal7 Aug 2022|12:00FA CupThe Glebe GroundThe Glebe GroundWhickhamGlobalFT
5 Aug 2023|14:00FTKnaresborough Town3 - 1Frickley AthleticFA CupKnaresborough Town AFC Ground3 Manse LaneKnaresboroughGlobal5 Aug 2023|14:00FA CupKnaresborough Town AFC Ground3 Manse LaneKnaresboroughGlobalFT
3 Aug 2024|14:00UnknownThackleyVSFrickley AthleticFA CupDennyfieldDennyfieldThackleyGlobal3 Aug 2024|14:00FA CupDennyfieldDennyfieldThackleyGlobalUnknown
2 Aug 2025|14:00FTBrighouse Town1 - 0Frickley AthleticFA CupThe Yorkshire Payments StadiumThe Yorkshire Payments StadiumBrighouse, West YorkshireGlobal2 Aug 2025|14:00FA CupThe Yorkshire Payments StadiumThe Yorkshire Payments StadiumBrighouse, West YorkshireGlobalFT
8 Aug 2026|14:00FTFrickley Athletic1 - 1CampionFA CupWestfield Lane StadiumWestfield LaneSouth ElmsallGlobal8 Aug 2026|14:00FA CupWestfield Lane StadiumWestfield LaneSouth ElmsallGlobalFT
EnglandWestfield Lane StadiumSouth Elmsall
EnglandWestfield Lane StadiumSouth ElmsallEnglandWestfield Lane StadiumSouth Elmsall