16 Aug 2014|14:00EndstandPeterborough Northern Star3 - 0Team BuryFA CupFocus Community CentreFocus Community CentrePeterboroughGlobal16 Aug 2014|14:00FA CupFocus Community CentreFocus Community CentrePeterboroughGlobalEndstand
30 Aug 2014|14:00EndstandPeterborough Northern Star0 - 2Mildenhall Town FCFA CupFocus Community CentreFocus Community CentrePeterboroughGlobal30 Aug 2014|14:00FA CupFocus Community CentreFocus Community CentrePeterboroughGlobalEndstand
15 Aug 2015|14:00EndstandPeterborough Northern Star1 - 2Newmarket TownFA CupMick George ArenaMick George ArenaPeterboroughGlobal15 Aug 2015|14:00FA CupMick George ArenaMick George ArenaPeterboroughGlobalEndstand
6 Aug 2016|14:00EndstandEynesbury Rovers3 - 1Peterborough Northern StarFA CupThe Alfred Hall Memorial GroundThe Alfred Hall Memorial GroundEynesburyGlobal6 Aug 2016|14:00FA CupThe Alfred Hall Memorial GroundThe Alfred Hall Memorial GroundEynesburyGlobalEndstand
5 Aug 2017|14:00EndstandPeterborough Northern Star2 - 3Deeping RangersFA CupBranch Bros StadiumBranch Bros StadiumPeterboroughGlobal5 Aug 2017|14:00FA CupBranch Bros StadiumBranch Bros StadiumPeterboroughGlobalEndstand
11 Aug 2018|14:00EndstandHiston6 - 1Peterborough Northern StarFA CupThe Glass World StadiumBridge RoadImpingtonGlobal11 Aug 2018|14:00FA CupThe Glass World StadiumBridge RoadImpingtonGlobalEndstand
10 Aug 2019|14:00EndstandWalsham Le Willows1 - 2Peterborough Northern StarFA CupSumner RoadSumner RoadWalsham-le-WillowsGlobal10 Aug 2019|14:00FA CupSumner RoadSumner RoadWalsham-le-WillowsGlobalEndstand
24 Aug 2019|14:00EndstandArlesey Town2 - 0Peterborough Northern StarFA CupaRMadillo StadiumHitchin RoadArleseyGlobal24 Aug 2019|14:00FA CupaRMadillo StadiumHitchin RoadArleseyGlobalEndstand
1 Sep 2020|18:45EndstandPeterborough Northern Star0 - 1Potton UnitedFA Cup1 Sep 2020|18:45FA CupEndstand
7 Aug 2021|14:00EndstandNewport Pagnell Town FC4 - 1Peterborough Northern StarFA Cup7 Aug 2021|14:00FA CupEndstand